Günter
Verheugen, Member of the European Commission Responsible for
Enlargement issue in terms of where the borders of the future
European Union shall be or the impact of Turkey on the nature of the
European integration project. We will have to take these and other
concerns seriously and be prepared to discuss them.
On its side, the EU will also have to examine
whether it is ready for Turkey's accession. It is clear that the
accession of a country with the size and population of Turkey would
have consequences on the functioning of the European Union. This would
fundamentally affect many policy areas and the functioning of the EU
institutions. The Commission has started to reflect on how to best meet
these challenges. We did the same when we embarked on negotiations with
the member states that acceded on 1 May. In
conclusion, the process of modernization of the Turkish political
system is underway. The Turkish Government continues to shown a steady
degree of determination to bring about political reforms, not only for
the sake of complying with the Copenhagen political criteria but
primarily for Turkey's own sake. I am well aware that there is an
impressive degree of consensus in Turkey in favour of joining the EU.
In the period immediately ahead of us, the
decision to be taken in December, will depend on Turkey's capacity to
demonstrate that it fulfils the Copenhagen political criteria, not only
in legal provisions, but also in practice.
These criteria were not invented for Turkey, but apply equally to all
candidates. For our report next October, as in previous years, we will
apply the same principles to Turkey as to all other candidate
countries. There should be no doubts that the report will be fair and
objective. (Extracts from the speech delivered
by Günter Verheugen, at a Conference organised by Friends of Europe on
June 2004) TURKVEN Evren Ünver co-founder of Turkven:
By İlker TEMİR Turkven is an independent
private equity firm in Turkey that is committed to supporting the
Turkish entrepreneurs for the long term. It has raised USD44 million
from a number of international, institutional investors including the
IFC (part of the World Bank Group), NBG (National Bank of Greece), FMO
(Dutch Development Bank), DEG (German Development Bank), EIB (European
Investment Bank) and TTGV (Turkish Technology Development Foundation).
We have interviewed Evren Unver; one of the three founders of Turkven.
ü How was Turkven founded, could you give some background? ü
"Turkven was founded by Seymur Tari, Eren Nil and myself in 2002. We
were all classmates in France during our MBA studies in 1997 and
decided to raise a private equity fund to invest in promising Turkish
companies. We began investigating the interest of corporate investors
in 2000, and formally launched our fund in March 2002. Our investors
are the IFC, NBG, FMO, DEG, EIB and TTGV. In addition to these
institutions, we have a strategic partnership with Advent
International, a Boston based private equity fund manager. Turkven is
the exclusive co-investment partner of Advent in Turkey, and we source
and pursue deals jointly with them. Together we aim to invest around
USD 100 million in 8-10 Turkish companies over the next 3-4 years. We
take minority or majority positions in companies, and take active board
member positions in the companies in which we invest. Last year we
invested in UNO, the leading packaged bread manufacturer in Turkey.
Currently we are in the final stages of completing our second
investment, which will be involved in business services. You can find
more information about Turkven at our website: www.turkven.com." ü Most
of your shareholders are European Banks. Why do you think they have
chosen to invest through Turkven?ü "Our investors are institutions with
significant debt and equity portfolios in Turkey. They are familiar
with the market and accustomed to the risks. Investing in Turkey
through a fund structure such as ours is a safer option for investors,
as we tend to be quite involved with our portfolio companies and help
with corporate governance."ü How do you interpret the latest economic
developments in Turkey? Is the country indeed heading towards greater
macro-economic stability and reaching its economic potential? "Turkey
is a rapidly evolving economy - things move quickly for the better, as
well as the worse. The 2001 financial shock was a huge burden on the
country, and we are still just reco-vering from it. I don't believe we
have cleared all of the hurdles facing us, but we are certainly on the
right track. Issues such as the current account deficit and overall
debt level are still alarming, but progress is being made. What we need
is a sustained period of no surprises - either economic or political."
ü Turkey seems to have difficulties to attract foreign investments when
compared to Eastern European countries. Why do you think this is the
case? ü "The path to EU integration certainly is a factor. If Turkey is
indeed given a positive signal in December to begin formal negotiations
this will likely lead to a trickle down effect of increased FDI.
However this isn't the only factor - Greece for example, despite being
an EU member, received even less FDI." ü What sectors is Turkven
interested in? ü "We are looking at many sectors across the board -
currently on our list of targets are business services,
pharmaceuticals, media, food & beverage, packaging, logistics,
automotive spare parts, telecoms, building materials to name a few." ü
What are the main advantages and obstacles for foreign investors in
Turkey?
ü "Turkey is a large market of 70m people, as well as a strategic
location for manufacturing, especially European-destined products with
a medium-to-high level of labor required. Electronics, white goods,
automotive components all benefit from Turkey's educated work force,
customs union with the EU, logistical proximity and established trade
ties. Difficulties include the legal framework, high taxes and
corruption." ü In the coming years, a high number of state owned
companies will be privatized in Turkey. What is Turkven's approach to
privatization? ü "It's important to approach state privatization
opportunities as "Management Buy-in" scenarios. As a fund manager we do
not have the know-how or capability to manage the companies we invest
in. Therefore we try to partner with companies and managers that have
in-depth knowledge and experience in the relevant sectors. If we can
find the right partners that we can trust will successfully lead the
management of the privatized company, we are definitely interested. We
have explored a few cases like this." ü There has been some recent
changes in the foreign investment law. How do you see the current
situation from a legal perspective?
ü "It is certainly improving. The approval process in Ankara for FDI
has been streamlined quite a bit. However there is still much work to
be done. I believe Ireland is a good example of how to attract
additional FDI by making the investment climate friendlier to
international institutions." ü What impact do you expect on the Turkish
economy if EU accession negotiations start?
ü "I believe many of the positive impacts of starting negotiations have
already been factored into the Turkish economy. The default scenario in
most companies’ planning is that Turkey will get the go ahead in
December. We are more worried about a backlash in case this does not
happen. However, if everything does go well, I expect we will see an
increase in the levels of FDI, as seen in Poland or the Czech republic."