YASED
the organisation of foreign investors in Turkey Şaban Erdikler Chairman
of YASED By Sofie Brutsaert "Even at world standards, new
legislation represents
important improvements" ü Is Turkey an attractive country for foreign
investors? "Yes it is. Turkey is the 17th largest economy in the
world worth nearly $490 billion. Half of its 70 million
population is between 15 and 25 years old! Turkey is neighbouring
important markets such as the EU, Russia, Central Asia, the Middle East
and the Mediterranean region. It is located at the crossroad of energy
roads, has a strong industry, possesses local entrepreneurial investors
and has a work force of 23 million people. Turkey is listed 8th in the
FIAS (Foreign Investment Advisory Service) report for middle level
manager staffing and has an urbanization level of 71.2%. Our country
signed agreements with nearly 50 countries preventing double taxation -
with Belgium in 1987 - and other regional and bilateral trade
agreements, such as the Customs Union. Turkey also signed the
International Arbitration Agreement and is working hard to implement
the EU 'acquis communautaire'. The actual reforms will obviously give
results in 2005-2006." ü What are the most frequent complaints coming
from foreign investors? ü "Foreign investors used to complain mostly
about the economic and political instability. However, they now have
confidence in the government and its policies. In order to maintain
this trust, we must keep on implementing these new policies. On the
other hand, the problems of Intellectual Property Rights must be
eliminated, pirating must be hindered, non-tariff barriers must be
reduced, laws must be implemented so as to become valid, and the
informal economy must definitely be tackled. The government is aware of
these problems and shows goodwill towards eliminating them. However,
the new laws must also be successfully implemented. Currently, one of
Turkey's main problems is not to have fulfilled the much needed
amendments on data protection. As a result, Turkey risks sanctions from
the EU. Within the framework of the Trade Barrier Regulation execution,
Turkey should comply with the data protection agreements that it has
signed, especially on pharmaceuticals, and should rapidly start their
implementation." ü Can you give some examples of recent reforms that
improved the investment climate?
ü "With the new Foreign Investment Law, minimum investment limit of
$50.000 and the requirement of permission from the General Directorate
of Foreign Investment have been removed. Accordingly, the equality
principle that already existed in the old law has been underlined in
the new one. This states that there will be no discrimination between
foreign and local investors. Another law supporting this idea is the
law that simplifies company establishments. With this new law, the
number of documents have been reduced to eight forms and the procedure
has been centralised to one office. Even at world standards these are
substantial improvements. Another novelty regarding the employment of
foreign employees is that 'key personnel' who will be working in
specified investments can now be able to obtain work permits within
fifteen days. Additionally, the long-awaited inflation accounting law
has finally been passed. Some laws on e-signature and data reach have
been adopted and will soon be implemented. All of these are major steps
and Turkey should be given some time to get results." ü Istanbul is the
economic heart of Turkey. Would you advise potential investors to also
choose Istanbul, or to broaden their horizon instead and consider other
regions?ü "Istanbul is at the centre of investments in Turkey.
Unfortunately, there is almost no free space available for new
investments in the Istanbul area. In addition to the shortage of space,
its infrastructure is also growing inadequate. However, other
developing axes are available in Turkey: the Aegean-Marmara and the
Aegean-Mediterranean Axes offer sufficient space and they are suitable
for investments with a similar infrastructure to the Istanbul region.
On the other hand, several investment locations are available within
the scope of the GAP project. GAP is a region which provides some
incentives and in which major Turkish investors such as Koç and Sabanci
Holding have recently invested. Thanks to the latest incentive law,
Turkey is offering various incentives to investors planning to invest
in 36 different cities. Cities like Bursa, Izmir, Gaziantep, Antalya,
Mersin and the surrounding cities, which have shown some progress as an
investment area, will become attraction centres for investors in the
near future." ü How do you see the evolution of the Turkish market? ü
"Almost all sectors are open to investment, especially IT,
infrastructure, energy, production, tourism and telecommunications all
of which show growth opportunities. Additionally, some sectors like the
car industry have reached a certain level of saturation.
Privatizations, especially the privatization of Turk Telekom, will
bring a certain revival to the telecommunications industry. Taking the
latest developments into account, we can say that we are rather
positive about starting the negotiations with the EU. Turkey and the EU
have a common history of more than 50 years. During this time, a
Customs Union agreement has been signed which is unprecedented between
the EU and a candidate country. Almost 80% of its exports are directed
to the EU countries. Over 60% of its foreign investments come from the
EU countries. These exchanges have already created a union and
continuous cooperation between Turkey and the EU. The next step should
be the start of the negotiations as soon as possible and we do believe
that Turkey will do it this year. Regarding Turkey's membership to the
EU, there is no insurmountable barrier for Turkey. A strong government
is governing Turkey. By carrying out reforms, this government
demonstrates that it is determined to harmonize its regulations so as
to conform to the EU 'acquis communautaire'." Günter Verheugen, Member
of the European Commission Responsible for Enlargement
Turkey is a candidate country. This was
confirmed by the heads of states and Governments in Helsinki in
December 1999. The issue we face is therefore not whether Turkey can be
a member of the EU, but whether and when negotiations on the accession
of Turkey can begin. The Copenhagen political criteria sets out the
conditions that needs to be met. The sequence is clear. First meeting
the political criteria and then negotiations.
The prospect of EU accession has proved to be a robust catalyst of
political transformation in Turkey. Since December 1999 Turkey embarked
upon a process of far-reaching constitutional and legislative reforms.
This process was substantially accelerated and deepened with the taking
up of office of the AKP Government in November 2002. Political reforms
have introduced changes ranging from improving civil liberties and
human rights to the role of the military. The reform process has
clearly addressed major issues and more importantly, highlight a
growing consensus in favour of liberal democracy.
One result of these reforms has been a
noticeable change of climate. Taboos have been broken. Civil society is
getting stronger and more organised. New channels have been set
up to allow people to report about cases of human rights violations and
the population appears to be more aware of its rights.
Issues whose mention could previously trigger
criminal proceedings, such as the role of the military, the Kurdish
language, or cases of torture and ill-treatment, are now freely
debated. There is public debate about equipping Turkey with a new and
modern constitution enshrining the basic values on which the EU is
based. In short, the reform process has brought a new mood of openness
and freedom in public debate in Turkey.
We don't under-estimate the scale of the
challenge for a country of the size and complexity of Turkey. The
changes to the Turkish political and legal system over the past years
are part of a longer-term process. It will take time before the spirit
of the reforms is fully reflected in the attitudes of executive and
judicial bodies, at all levels and throughout the country. But what
matters is the steady determination to overcome hurdles and
bureaucratic bottlenecks, and to establish a clear track record of
progressive implementation of the reforms.
If the European Council decides to open
negotiations with Turkey accession is not a formality, and not for
tomorrow. The negotiations will take time, reflecting the scale
of the difficulties in many sectors faced by such a large and complex
country. At the same time, a decision to open accession negotiations
does not mean that the political criteria will no longer be on the
agenda.
We will have to continue to monitor very
closely further progress achieved in this area as we did with all other
candidate countries. Turkey's candidature for
EU membership leaves nobody indifferent. There will and should be a
debate in Turkey and in the EU. There are those who are concerned about
the capacity of the Union to integrate a country of the size and with
the demography of Turkey. Others see the