Turkish-Belgian
Business Council boosts economic relations Paul Vanfrachem
President of TBBC : "I'm charmed by Turkey, as a person and as a
businessman" ü Mr. Vanfrachem, you are the
President of the Turkish-Belgian Business Council. Can you explain why
this organisation was founded and what its aims are?
ü TBBC was founded in 1989 by the Federation of
Belgian Enterprises (FEB) and DEIK, a consortium of Turkish employers
organisations. The objective was to improve the business relations
between Belgium and Turkey. In the first years, TBBC was working very
well under the guidance of an enthusiastic president, but after this
period it became inactive. In early 2003, our Turkish colleagues of
DEIK asked the FEB to re-launch this council. The Belgian partner
answered positively, thinking that it was a good idea to strengthen
business ties between both countries. I have accepted to take up the
presidency and used my experience with Turkey as a businessman to boost
contacts. We have organised several meetings to present the Turkish
economy and its growth potential to Belgian businessmen. Also, we
participated in the economic mission led by Prince Philippe a few
months ago, and organised a seminar which targeted Belgian businessmen
who want to export to Turkey. Our aim is to organise similar seminars
in Turkey in the near future to explain the Belgian economy. My
co-chairman on the Turkish side is Mr Yuce. ü
You had worked for the international cement company CBR for a very long
time. During your career, you had close relations with Turkey and
played an important role in CBR's investment there. Why did CBR decide
to invest in Turkey? ü This investment can be
placed in the framework of our general strategy. Cement is a local
business activity and in Belgium, we have reached our maximum capacity
as a market leader. The only option was to diversify geographically by
acquiring cement companies in countries for which we have foreseen a
growth in cement consumption. Turkey was clearly one of them. In 1995,
we invested 300 million dollars to buy a plant in Canakkale.
Afterwards, we merged it with a plant of the Sabanci group in Marmara.
Since then, we are partners with the Sabanci group on a 50-50 basis. A
third plant of our group is situated in the Black Sea region. The
general turnover is 170 million dollars a year with a workforce of a
thousand employees. We sell around 4 million tons of cement every year
and we are currently the market leader in the Marmara region.
ü You have chosen a well known Turkish company
for business partnership. Was this important for you?
ü To choose a good and reliable local partner
is also part of our strategy. We are specialised in producing and
selling cement. That is the know-how and expertise that we can offer to
the countries where we invest. But we are also convinced that we should
respect the local culture. Especially when that culture differs from
your own, a local partner is always a good solution. Your counterparts
know the local traditions, the way to handle things, the local network
and the authorities. The drawback of such a partnership is that you are
less free than if you were alone… just like in a marriage, you have to
take the ideas of your partner into account too! However, our
experience with the Sabanci group is very positive.
ü After working intensively in Turkey for nine
years, in your opinion, what are the most important assets of Turkey as
an investment country? ü In the first years of
our investment, we were very happy. Then, unfortunately the earthquake
near Istanbul was a big shock and caused a slow down in the economy.
The financial crisis and the devaluation of the Turkish Lira in 2001
was another economic slump which had a negative impact on our business.
Despite these events, our company has never suffered a loss. We regard
them as mere micro-economic disruptions and still believe in the great
potential of the Turkish economy on the long run. It is undoubtedly a
growing market and a developing country. Many of the population and
infrastructural needs must be fulfilled. Do not forget that this is a
huge market with 70 million people! When you leave the big cities in
Turkey, you can see the needs everywhere around you… Another big asset
of Turkey as an investment country is that Turkish people are hard
workers at all levels, very professional and highly educated. You can
find excellent and dedicated local managers. For instance, our company
recruited nearly all its managers locally. Finally, I hope that the
positive attitude of Belgian people and politicians towards accepting
Turkey as an EU member state - like our minister of Foreign Affairs, Mr
Louis Michel - will also be a reason to maintain good economic
relations. The Belgian business community strongly supports Turkey's
membership too since it would certainly facilitate trade even more
between the two countries.ü However, there are
surely some aspects that can be improved… ü
Certainly, there are some. We still encounter some trade barriers. And
the Turkish market is not a totally free market yet. Many state-owned
companies are still active and they do not always comply with the same
rules as the private sector, which lead to unfair competition.
Furthermore, I would plead for more transparent laws, which I consider
as the main obstacle for the moment. Energy supply today is not quite
reliable and prices are high compared to other countries. There might
even be a shortage of electricity in the forthcoming years. For the
energy-consuming business like ours, this is another concern.
ü You mentioned about the cultural differences
in doing business and the importance of having a local partner to
overcome them. Could you describe us those differences ?
ü Whether you like it or not, the 'relations
network' is of much higher importance than in the western countries
like Belgium. Secondly, people are more emotionally involved while
doing business, but that is the case not only in Turkey but also in all
Mediterranean countries like Greece, Italy… Moreover, I have found out
that Turks are highly flexible. These are the main differences.
Personally, I was not confronted with great cultural differences. What
might be problematic for the development of the Turkish economy is the
deficiency in tax collection. And the black market is still very
important, people should show more citizenship.